Tags: play chess online, chess online, play chess, play chess, play chess online, chess online, backgammon online
Chess Forum mailcafe.net << online chess - < chess - chess > - chess online >>
| From | Message | Posted by scottpb mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 11:24:52 Play online chess | Subject: end game
Message: here's a question regarding choices of pieces in an endgame.
is it better to have
A) King, a bishop and 5 pawns vs King, knight and 4 pawns
B) King, rook, bishop & 4 pawns vs King, rook, knight & 3 pawns
sometimes decisions for the endgame can be difficult
any thoughts?
| Posted by bananaman1 mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 13:55:07 Play online chess |
Message: depends on position of pawns.
| Posted by wschmidt mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 14:05:50 Play online chess | I think....
Message: this is too general a question to be able to provide a meaningful answer. There are too many unknown variables. Are the pawns on both sides of the board or just one side? Are the rooks on open files? Are the bishops good or bad? Are the knights actively placed? Are the kings centralized? Are you defending or attacking? Do you need a win or will a draw suffice? ——— On chess: Teacher makes game fun, fun, fun — Chess can sometimes serve as a big brother. "It helped us stay out of trouble, especially after school," said Luis Garcia, 23. "It kept us safe." Garcia is a former student to Patrick Neely, a retired teacher, veteran chess guru and longtime surfer who runs a "Surf 'n' Chess" program at an elementary school in Glendale, Ariz. His disciples immerse themselves in an environment of chess, Beach Boys tunes and other oldies in the school cafeteria. Neely's program confers benefits in addition to keeping kids off the streets. "It makes you think. It's strategy," Garcia said. The chess novices are also taught respect for themselves and others. They shake hands with their opponents and wish them well before ...
Posted by umpito mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 15:26:07 Play online chess |
Message: Rook and bishop work better together than rook and knight so, other considerations aside, I would take the latter.
Dan ——— Disqualified by Evidence on a Phone — A German master was disqualified from his country’s chess championship tournament this month, done in by his cellphone. Officials determined that the master, Christoph Natsidis, 23, had consulted a computer program on his smartphone during his game against the grandmaster Sebastian Siebrecht in the last round. Natsidis made repeated trips to the bathroom, for 8 to 10 minutes at a time. Siebrecht offered him a draw, which Natsidis accepted. Afterward, a tournament referee asked to see Natsidis’s phone and found a chess program on it with a position from the game. A message sent to Natsidis’s Facebook page asking him for comment was not answered. Natsidis’s disqualification cost ...
Posted by bucklehead mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 16:45:03 Play online chess | All things being equal
Message: I'd take the bishop and 5 pawns. Engames with a lot of pawns are often easier than those with fewer, and with fewer pieces the bishop probably has more freedom to roam. If you can find a way to swap B for N and enter a 5p v 4p scenario, you're in pretty good shape for a win; if you swap minor pieces in the other scenario and are left with a one-pawn advantage with the rooks still on the board, your extra pawn may only draw the game. ——— Vishy Anand crushes Alexey Shirov with bravura performance — Vishy Anand, the world chess champion, has responded to the limp draws in the candidates matches and the surprise victory there of Israel's Boris Gelfand by restating his own credentials with a bravura performance. Anand's chess match in Leon against Spain's ex-Latvian No1 Alexey Shirov was only one-hour rapid chess but the Indian won it in style, 4.5-1.5. His three wins included the brilliancy below plus a move six novelty as Black in the solid Caro-Kann which proved so strong that the demoralised Shirov resigned his wretched position as early as move 17. At 41 Anand keeps himself in excellent professional shape. Spain is his European base and he splits his time between training there with ...
Posted by scottpb mailcafe.net
9/21/2005 17:41:54 Play online chess | THANKS
Message: SO, the pawn positions are roughly equal
a related ? is bishop or knight is better in the end game with 5 and 4 pawns, respectively.
It would seem that the concensus is bishop as the bishop has a greater range.
Thanks
I'll let you know how it works out
-- Scott ——— Kasparov launches “chess for schools” plan in EU — When it comes to encouraging children to do better at school, Gary Kasparov says the answer is in black and white. After several successful years in the US, the former world chess champion wants to introduce his Chess in Schools programme across the EU. Kasparov’s not-for-profit foundation hopes the European Parliament will give the go-ahead for a roll-out in September. It helps them with the curriculum.” he told reporters in Brussels,“it has great social effect, integrating kids from very different social backgrounds. It is also a very important element in this time of economic hardship – it is cheap. Computers will play a central role in the programme, giving students the opportunity to learn chess ...
Posted by gajolen mailcafe.net
9/22/2005 00:24:28 Play online chess |
Message: A general rule is that Bishops are better in the end game when there are pawn islands in both side of the board, due to their longe range. Knights are a short range piece, so they will be better when there are only pawns in 1 side of the board.
But as with every other general chess rule there are many ecxeptions. Do the bishop have any targets, how far the pawns, where are the kings and so on.
Also I dont mean to offend you, but i dont understand in your question why do you give 1 pawn more for the bishop side ?
All other things aside it is better to have a pawn more so i would go with the K+B and five pawns. Still it depends on the position, but if the position is equal it is easyer to have a pawn more. ——— Improve your endgame play — Finishing a chess game can be a difficult task. Both players are usually tired at the end of a long game, and as a result, many chess players, both beginner and advanced, see their endgame play suffer. Luckily, you have the benefit of reading this informative article, so hopefully you can begin improving your endgame play today! Playing quickly at the end of the game is a typical mistake of the inexperienced chess player. Just because there are fewer pieces on the board, this does not mean things are simple. Accuracy is more important in the endgame, as even one slip can turn the game from a win to a draw or a draw to a loss – or even worse, a win to a loss … but let’s not even talk about that. The first way to ...
Posted by mightytiny mailcafe.net
9/22/2005 03:10:00 Play online chess |
Message: As wschmidt said, given just the numbers of pieces in the options, it is impossible to give any meaningful advice; there are so many factors other than the numbers of remaining pieces, and indeed, these unmentioned factors are invariably quite crucial in determining which would be better.
It's just as well though that the help you'll get from any advice will be minimal, because asking something of others that would help you to make a choise in an ongoing game is against the correspondence chess rules.
You'd do much better to play the position without any advice (regardless of what level of usefulness - or uselessness - that advice might be), and then take the position where you were wondering this question, and present it on the board after the game is over; then you can ask a more specific question (how to trade down to an endgame in this position?), and people, seeing the position, can actually tell you what things to look at when making a decision such as that... and that newly acquired knowledge you can take to your future midgame-endgame transitions.
| Posted by scottpb mailcafe.net
9/22/2005 05:25:52 Play online chess | good advice
Message: Thanks again, all.
I think the idea of giving the board pos'n later is a good one.
And I pretty much got the answer
in general a bishop is better than a knight in endgame.
also, it is very informative that there are so many variables and that even a small difference in pos'n on the board can greatly influence the strategy one takes.
I really didn't expect so much discussion- so, i have a much better idea of how to use the forum now and I look forward to more soon.
Thanks again all
Scott
| Posted by i_play_slowly mailcafe.net
9/25/2005 18:05:44 Play online chess | knights vs. bishops
Message: gajolen wrote, "A general rule is that Bishops are better in the end game when there are pawn islands in both side of the board"; it doesn't necessarilly follow that "in general a bishop is better than a knight in endgame." As gajolen noted, it all depends on the pawns. If the pawns interlock in the center of the board, they might give your bishop no room to move. Your opponent could even make a point of creating such a position in order to suffocate your bishop. Bishops love open games; knights prefer closed games, because they can leap over a wall of pawns.
*
Another consideration: If your opponent has a pawn on an open file, and its promtion square is not the same color as your bishop, you could have problems stopping the promotion. Again, it all comes down to the pawns.
| Posted by cedsed mailcafe.net
10/05/2005 18:50:54 Play online chess | Cheating
Message: It seems advice was asked for and given regarding an ongoing game.
Justin
| Posted by danders mailcafe.net
10/05/2005 21:17:30 Play online chess | Justin
Message: No particular position was from any particular game was included in the question. If you're going to throw the word 'cheat' around in reference to your fellow players, you'd best have proof, and you should probably report it directly to the admin.
Personally, I've about had it up to here with unfounded accusations of that nature.
| Posted by honololou mailcafe.net
10/05/2005 22:41:27 Play online chess | danders
Message: It is possible to seek and gain advice without citing specific positions. Scott's original question
was actually fairly specific and it seems clear that he was referring to a specific game and not
wondering in the abstract.
cedsed, read the posts. Scott has already been warned and seems to have got the message.
No need to throw around the "C" word.
| Posted by danders mailcafe.net
10/05/2005 22:55:14 Play online chess |
Message: Several others seem to think it was abstract enough not to be of much specific help. If someone feels that there is enough evidence to warrant an accusation, I would think it more helpful to send it along to the admin than sling it around the forums.
Perhaps I am mistaken.
| Posted by misato mailcafe.net
10/05/2005 23:58:30 Play online chess | within the limits
Message: If I had an endgame King&bishop&knight vs. naked King, I definitely would look up the technique in a book. There I will get the general information I need to mate the opponent - without regard to our specific position. In my opinion this is within the limits.
Scott did the same, instead of a book he "looked up" in the GK-community - also without regard to a specific position. He got back general advices which could be looked up in books as well (and are well known to experienced players). His task is/was to think about those advices for his own position.
Furthermore it is always a problem that tactical issues (knight fork!) have to be considered from move to move, so the given advices may have been false because his opponents knight might have an excellent position.
Playing endgames by general advices is far more difficult than to follow a written opening-line, a "won" position (by book) oftenly slips into a draw - and you dont know what you did wrong (and when)!
An additional very general advice: In about equal positions better follow the rule "the fewer the tokens the more moves to plan (and time to think!)".
Good luck for your games, hopefully you and your opponent learn a lot from this endgame. Feel free to publish it here after its end, someone will find the time to add some comments to yours.
| Posted by scottpb mailcafe.net
10/06/2005 05:08:21 Play online chess | thanks
Message: well, shoot fire.
as it turns out the advice was pretty 'abstract' and that's exactly what I wanted. I did not request, at least that was my intent, not to get specific advice but to think about some ideas of endgames.
All your input has been helpful and I thank you all for your thoughts and input.
The game I was playing really triggered the general question and if this happens in the future I can easily wait until the end of the game that got me thinking. no worries here. So, thanks all for the msg's. Perhaps we can play sometime.
Scott
| Posted by bucklehead mailcafe.net
10/06/2005 11:33:02 Play online chess | If the game is over...
Message: ...why not post the board link here, so you can get a more concrete assessment?
|
| | | | |
|