Tags: chess online, chess online, chess online, chess, play chess online, chess online, sudoku
Chess Forum mailcafe.net << - < - > - >>
| From | Message | Posted by tim_b mailcafe.net
1/09/2007 15:44:24 play online chess | Subject: GK and real boards.
Message: When I first came on GK, I re-enacted some games on real boards (hi-jacked the dining room table) because I felt and still feel that there is no better way to "read" a game.
Do most people do this? Is it important to see things in 3-D?
Cheers,
Tim.
| Posted by caro-kann mailcafe.net
1/09/2007 15:53:09 play online chess | Well,
Message: I guess that it may have some sort of effect (personally I don't feel much), but I prefer 2D games, probably because of no interference (i.e the birds-eye view) from other objects blocking my line of sight. It would seem that in OTB 3D games, I need the same bird's eye view as in 2D to perform well
| Posted by ganstaman mailcafe.net
1/09/2007 16:22:35 play online chess |
Message: I prefer the 2-D look, I believe. Playing so much online and reading books (well, actually I think just 'book') and magazines will get you used to this view.
When I play live, I often stand up and feel I can see the board better that way. By getting over the board like this, I make it seem more 2D than 3D.
Still, changing boards or sets does make the whole position look different. It's probably good in a difficult position where you want to get a different perspective on the board to hopefully get you to see the right move (similar to how I will sometimes merely flip the board around to see it in a whole new light).
| Posted by bucklehead mailcafe.net
1/10/2007 06:58:24 play online chess | We're geezers...
Message: The first thing that occurred to me when I read this post was to check the ages of the posters...our lead author tim_b is 34 and ganstaman is a sprightly 21. I'd be willing to wager that, the younger the chessplayer, the more likely he/she is to prefer a computer screen (or, at least, profess there's no difference).
These days, I've gotten lazy and started to analyze/move based solely on the 2D display. But since I'm 36, there's really no substitute for a physical board and physical pieces. It's what I grew up on, and making the shift to computer-based chess proved very difficult for me. I still find that my analysis is better if I can sit down and get my hands on the pieces--I have a very nice and heavy plastic set (and floppy mousepad board) for regular analysis, but if things get nasty I pull out my ebony pieces and onyx board. I'd keep the nice set out all the time, except for the fact that I have three small children, the littlest of whom would no doubt attempt to eat the chessmen. All at once, if he can manage it.
For this reason, there is no piece of chess gear I lust after more than the DGT eboard ( -> www.dgtprojects.com ). But as aforementioned, there are kids in the picture, and therefore no disposable income.
Let there be woodpushing!
| Posted by wschmidt mailcafe.net
1/10/2007 12:33:57 play online chess | Well, I'm 57...
Message: and I really never got into chess seriously until the advent of chess engines and on-line play. A large part of the reason was I don't have the kind of chess memory that allows me to quickly reset pieces back to an original position after analyzing a variation. I either had to keep two boards going, have a diagram in a book, or only do a couple of moves into a line. Only when the "back" button could get me back quickly and easily did analysing stop being an exercise in frustration for me.
I still enjoy occasionally setting up a board to read over a game, but only for fun where I don't follow the variations too deeply. Otherwise that old frustration sets in again.
| Posted by tim_b mailcafe.net
1/11/2007 13:37:34 play online chess | Thanks
Message: Thanks for the response, everyone, I am starting to acclimatise to 2-D now and understand the point about an unfettered birds eye view.
LOL, bucklehead ! I know what you mean – “Eek! Time to pull the big guns out!” No kids, but I’ve got a puppy to watch out for and people reclaiming the dining table! ;0)
wschmidt I see what you are saying about the limitations of bringing out the wood, but I can’t analyse deeply like that and replace the pieces faithfully either, it’s difficult to put my finger on it, but I feel there’s something about seeing the real board in 3-D that makes things a bit clearer on occasion.
Cheers,
Tim.
| Posted by bunta mailcafe.net
1/14/2007 00:53:08 play online chess | I know a guy
Message: I know a guy, one of my mates who plays so much playchess that when it comes to over the board games he stands up to try and get the 2D view and calculates from there. So 3D view seems a little bit wierd for him lol. Quite funny really, I'm trying to get used to both. I think everyone should, as it helps in all ways especially when your playing.
| Posted by kansaspatzer mailcafe.net
1/14/2007 23:15:29 play online chess |
Message: I see on 3D much better, but I'm playing 40 games at once, I don't have time to set them all up.
| Posted by doctor_knight mailcafe.net
1/20/2007 09:33:18 play online chess |
Message: I like both. But if you are an over the board player, you have to get used to the real board. If all you ever look at is a 2d board, when you finally play on a real board, you will very likely make mistakes because you are not used to the board. I have made a number of pathetic mistakes because I found it difficult to visualize the position on certain boards that I was not used to. Even the tournament boards caused errors for me at first (of course that's not the only reason for the mistakes but had a lot to do with some of the more obvious blunders). I don't play out my gameknot games on a 3d board, but I think it is good to go to the club at least once a weak and not necesarily just play games but do a lot of study and analysis with your friends on the tournament board. That way you get used to seeing a position on the real board. Now the tournament board is the best board for me to use I think. Especially with those nice heavy weight pieces that my friend has.
| Posted by wote mailcafe.net
1/20/2007 11:29:40 play online chess | yes
Message: I think it's a good idea to see the game in 3D as you call it.Especially if you’re an over the board player, like in a club. I don’t always do this for GameKnot, but you should always do it when playing against your computer. It give you the same advantage, that the computer has. – being able to move the men around and look at possibilities. But ultimately you should be able to see the moves in your mind without any help of any kind. Play lots practise!!
|
Chess news:
Magnus Carlsen fights to the top -- The chess battle of the moment is Magnus Carlsen's fight to equal and surpass the established trio of Vishy Anand, Vlad Kramnik and Veselin Topalov who have held the world chess crown since 2005 but are all 15-20 years older than the 18-year-old Norwegian. Carlsen is consistently in the top five in the chess rankings and is virtually sure of a place in the next world title candidates event in 2010 or 2011. This year, too, he scored significant individual victories against Anand at Linares and against Topalov on the Bulgarian's home patch. Kramnik has proved tougher and has a large overall plus against the teenager. So last week, when Carlsen led Kramnik by half a point ...
Kramnik wins Dortmund, again -- ... Another former world chess champion, Anatoly Karpov of Russia, is painfully demonstrating that chess is a young man's game. Karpov, arguably the most successful chess grandmaster in history, suffered five losses and occupied last place at 1-6 with two games remaining in the 10-player round robin in Donostia, Spain. Karpov faces long odds in making a return to elite competition at age 58. The oldest chess players who compete regularly at that level are Boris Gelfand, 41, of Israel and Vassily Ivanchuk, 40, of Ukraine. In contrast, U.S. chess champion Hikaru Nakamura, 21, began with a fantastic 5 1/2 -1 1/2 . Nakamura lacks experience in international events, but this type of chess ...
International chess news -- Hikaru Nakamura, the U.S. chess champion, and Ukraine chess star Ruslan Ponomariov tied for first in the grandmaster round robin in Donostia, Spain. Each scored 6 1/2 -2 1/2 , and Nakamura won a speed chess playoff to officially claim first prize. Nakamura, only 21, is already a legend for his skill at speed chess. In Donostia, he showed a mature style, winning most games after trading Queens. He plans to compete in two more elite chess tournaments this year. Karpov suffered almost certainly the worst performance in history by any of the all-time chess greats. ...
|
|